Bradley Austrin
English II
5/22/09
After watching the documentary film our English class worked on nearly the whole semester creating, filming, and editing, there is no doubt that I would take some time to evaluate the documentary as a whole. Every documentary film has its upsides and downsides. Our documentary, The Future is in Our Hands: Live Sustainably, is no different from any other documentary in this very way.
A documentary is created as a way to inform the viewer about whatever subject is being covered. I feel that our documentary has fulfilled this task only moderately. Throughout the film, the class presented a tiny amount of facts in the film, some with narration, others with images and video that always attempt to appeal to a person’s pathos, like when facts about deaths due to our environmental mistakes were shown near the middle of the documentary. However, I do not believe that it was enough to persuade the viewer into actually making enough change in their life. Sure, the viewer may say they will change, but not enough strong and convincing facts were given to enable a total realization in that person’s mind. Although little information is given at times, a viewer’s pathos would most defiantly still be slightly tickled. This is seen especially during some of the film’s visual metaphors, when the viewer has to infer what is going on based on the visual being displayed. When that person realizes what they are seeing, it helps them gain knowledge, and they learn something from that clip. If a human were to gain an emotional thought from something they watch, it is a good thing. It also means that the film has done enough justice to make a decent persuasion in the mind of the viewer. I believe that our documentary has done just that, and in some ways, it has done it very well.
The documentary, like a PC, has many things that work, and slightly fewer things that did not quite work as well as it were suppose to. Throughout our documentary, we had many bright moments. This is most apparent in the camera position seen in the film. The camera work went very well, as it would stay mostly steady, keeping what needs to be seen on frame on frame. The students in the class were able to follow the rule of thirds, and most importantly, being sure not to allow anything on frame loses position or gets even the slightest bit cut off. I also feel we did quite well with our visual metaphors. Each visual metaphor in the film was creative, and very unique from another metaphor used by other groups. Our metaphors were also mostly easy to understand. This is a great thing to have for a documentary, as it helps the viewer obtain a larger pathos then with a generic metaphor with little understanding. Another thing that I felt worked truly well in the film was the presentation and flow of the entire thing. Transitioning into another topic worked, and worked very smoothly, without any problems present. The flow of the film was very steady, while staying interesting, and never getting to a dull moment. For the most part, our documentary worked quite well.
Nothing is ever perfect. Everything has flaws, even if it is the slightest little detail. Our documentary is no different, and contains many flaws that can easily be fixed. The first flaw that I noticed was the cutting from interview to fact. The transitioning here was seen as a bit on the choppy side, sometimes cutting audio away too fast, keeping audio too long, or just a rough move into the next screen. If the groups took a bit more time on this problem, it would have defiantly improved. The second problem I noticed was quiet narration. At times when someone spoke narration during the film (most specifically during the “What is Sustainable Living” group), it was too hard to hear, and typically blocked by background sound. This problem also had a potentially easy fix, though that fix was never used. The final problem I noticed was that the text used at times was a bit hard to read (very apparent in the “What is Sustainable Living” group). Though not a big problem due to narration in most parts with text, it could have easily been avoided. Overall, the documentary had many problems, mostly quite minor, and not too bad enough to affect the overall message presented.
After dedicating a great amount of time to this documentary, I have no doubt learned a great amount from everything I have done in the past couple of months. I had never known that the world was in such bad shape as I have just researched for the documentary. Usually, the things I hear about the earth are only “tiny problems” with the world. The bigger facts about the earth and its environment are more enclosed away, almost waiting for someone to find them, like a treasure locked away in a treasure chest, which can only be opened with a specific key. I also learned that the world does not make the larger problems in the world more known to the public. If people were to make it more known, then the problems kept away would be lessened to the amount that is actually told and known to the public. While using the camera, I learned how to film things better. If I wanted to become a director, or even a film editor, I would use the knowledge I learned in class to my advantage. Our documentary also taught me how to be more organized. While editing the film, I had to set up a work schedule for time I would put into the project, whether after school, in class, or even during Academic Lab. This would be a fantastic tool for me in the future, if I am ever in charge of a project. The final thing that I learned is that working with a larger group is harder, and takes a lot of work to get things to work out. Most of the time, you have disagreements. However, in the end, everyone comes together at last, to finalize the project. This documentary has practically taught me a whole lot of information that I could use for the rest of my life.
The things I have learned from the documentary are practically too large to count. There is no doubt that I would put them to good use in the future. Wherever my fate rests, I will be sure to think back to this project, and not make some of the same mistakes made here. I have gained a great amount of knowledge for organizing a large project. Instead of being completely clueless on what do do with a future project, I will think back to some of the things I learned here, like a better way of organization, and lead to a more successful project. I always like to think “One failure in life leads to a larger success down the road.” I want to see how this quote will come true, at a time when I use the mistakes made this semester, and some of the things I should have done from the start while working on this documentary.
Our documentary film, The Future is in Our Hands: Live Sustainably, will always be an important landmark in my life during education. I have learned a lot about the environment, organization, how to prevent mistakes, how not to work with a uncooperative group, etc. I feel that in the future, the knowledge I have gained will become very valuable to me. The future will look brighter, with more mistakes in my life possibly prevented due to this great learning experience